Southern Souvenir: Buttermilk Pie

By Christopher Matthews

The maternal side of my family, the Smiths, are from West Tennessee farming stock (east of Memphis, around Jackson). And the Smith women, many of whom taught in the county schools during the school year, and cooked for their farmer husbands in the planting/growing season, were quite adept in the kitchen, none more so than my grandmother, Mary Webb Smith, a.k.a. “Mom”. Her scratch baking skills in particular—delectable rolls, breads, cakes and pies—
remain legendary; fortunately, we had the good sense to record and transcribe her assortment of recipes and favorite dishes while she was still with us, now a treasured family legacy.

My mother, Mary Adelia, is certainly competent in the kitchen. But her older sister, Patti Bryant, my aunt, not only favors Mom in her looks (increasingly so, with the passage of time), but she also had more time with Mom in the kitchen during her formative cooking years, and absorbed the nuances. She’s the true bridge to the family’s culinary heritage.

But times does fly. A few weeks ago, all the first cousins and their broods gathered at my aunt Patti’s and uncle Bill’s house in Jackson, TN, to celebrate their 80th birthdays (as well as their 59th wedding anniversary). For Patti, 80 is the new 65 — she’s as active and engaging as ever. And while she got the night off from cooking when we gathered at her place on a Saturday night to celebrate, she had baked two Buttermilk pies, a family favorite.

Patti Bryant's Buttermilk Pie recipe

If you’ve never had it, Buttermilk pie is a custard-type dessert similar to that southern icon, Chess pie. But owing to the buttermilk, its texture is creamier and less dense than the traditional Chess pie, and it’s also a tad less sweet. The rich yellow-gold custard filling turns golden brown on top, and is a toothsome contrast to a crunchy pie crust.  Doesn’t get much better (and great cold at breakfast)!

Example of a Buttermilk Pie (but not Patti's)

The recipe above came straight out of Patti’s recipe box. Like many of the recipes derived from Mom, my great aunts and others from that generation, the directions are minimal — they assume baking acumen (on your part).

It also calls for a stick of margarine, which might give some pause. Alternatively, you could substitute a stick of unsalted butter, along with a pinch of salt (as margarine contains some salt). Just realize the pie will taste richer. You add and combine the ingredients in the order written, and it’s essential that the buttermilk is added last, and that the filling is not over-mixed.

Crust is another matter. Either buy an organic pre-made, uncooked pie shell, or make your own pie dough, aiming for a thinner, flaky crust.

Happy baking, y’all!

This entry was posted in Food, Home Baking, Travel and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Southern Souvenir: Buttermilk Pie

  1. wvfarm2u says:

    I lost a husband (born and raised in Tennessee) to cancer years ago and thought I had moved through the pain but when I read this I realized he had never made his family’s buttermilk pie for me! Now I’m MAD!!!! **kidding**

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s